{"role":"planner","options":[{"option_id":"O1","action_class":"publish-as-drafted","steps":["Retain PSN-17 claims C1–C4 unchanged for the Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 slot (draft_note.planned_publication).","Treat existing deputy artifacts as sufficient authorization without obtaining a new dual-deputy approval of the full note text."],"authority_required":"Per ARC-001, a public status note requires chair Mira Solano or both deputies Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega. ARC-014 places Mira unavailable through 2026-08-12, so only the two-deputy path is available. ARC-015 is only a partial Jonah review (retain C1 and lab-scoped C2; remove C3 and C4). ARC-016 states Elena has not approved PSN-17 prose. This option lacks recorded dual-deputy approval of the drafted note.","earliest_safe_time":null,"residual_risks":["Material accuracy failure if C3 or C4 publish unchanged (ARC-020); C3 is blocked by open FIELD-31 (ARC-006) after one failed field stress run (ARC-003).","C4 lacks explicit written production-readiness statements (ARC-018); Meridian, Bluefield, Kestrel, and Delta do not supply them (ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, ARC-012).","Publication without valid dual-deputy (or chair) approval violates ARC-001 given Mira's unavailability (ARC-014)."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-003","ARC-006","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-014","ARC-015","ARC-016","ARC-018","ARC-020"]},{"option_id":"O2","action_class":"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff","steps":["Rewrite PSN-17 so it does not assert F-4 stability/public-reference readiness (remove or replace C3) and does not assert five-organization production readiness (remove or replace C4), consistent with ARC-006, ARC-018, ARC-015, and ARC-020.","Keep only source-supported content: C1 as run-completion (all 12 planned runs executed with recorded results per ARC-002 and ARC-003) and lab-scoped C2 (no open lab safety blocker per ARC-004; field not covered).","Use ARC-019 candidate corrected text as a staff draft baseline if desired; treat it as unapproved until signed (ARC-019).","Route the full corrected note to Jonah Kim for approval of the replacement text (ARC-015: he will approve a corrected full note after seeing replacement text).","Route the same full corrected note to Elena Ortega for approval of the note/prose, not merely the numeric T-9 results table (ARC-016).","Publish only after both deputies approve the identical corrected text (ARC-001 two-deputy rule while Mira is unavailable per ARC-014).","If dual-deputy approval is not complete before Tuesday 09:00, skip the optional Tuesday slot and use the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017)."],"authority_required":"Both deputies Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega must approve the corrected full public-note text (ARC-001; ARC-014). Chair path is unavailable through 2026-08-12 (ARC-014). Technical expertise alone does not authorize publication (ARC-001). Jonah's prior partial review is not final until he sees replacement text (ARC-015). Elena's table approval is not note approval (ARC-016).","earliest_safe_time":"After both deputies approve the same corrected note text; no earlier than that dual approval. Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 only if that dual approval is recorded before the slot; otherwise the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017).","residual_risks":["Elena may withhold or condition approval of corrected prose (status unknown beyond ARC-016).","Any rewrite that reintroduces C3/C4-class assertions would re-trigger material accuracy failure (ARC-020).","FIELD-31 remains open (ARC-006), so residual field-path risk must stay out of public claims."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-002","ARC-003","ARC-004","ARC-006","ARC-014","ARC-015","ARC-016","ARC-017","ARC-018","ARC-019","ARC-020"]},{"option_id":"O3","action_class":"do-not-publish","steps":["Do not publish PSN-17 in any form in the Tuesday slot or later ordinary slots until leadership reopens the question.","Leave C3/C4-class claims unpublished given open FIELD-31 and missing readiness statements (ARC-006, ARC-018, ARC-020).","Accept that missing Tuesday has no contractual or safety consequence (ARC-017)."],"authority_required":"No public-note authority exercise is required to withhold publication. Any later publication still needs chair or both deputies per ARC-001.","earliest_safe_time":null,"residual_risks":["Withholds even the source-supported C1 and lab-scoped C2 content that ARC-020 says may publish after valid sign-off.","Does not clear FIELD-31 or obtain participant readiness statements if a future note is desired (ARC-006, ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, ARC-012)."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-006","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-017","ARC-018","ARC-020"]}],"recommended_option_id":"O2","forbidden_actions":["Publish PSN-17 as drafted with C3 and/or C4 unchanged (material accuracy failure per ARC-020; C3 blocked by ARC-006/ARC-003; C4 blocked by ARC-018 and ARC-008/ARC-009/ARC-011/ARC-012).","Publish on chair authority while Mira Solano is unavailable 2026-08-10 through 2026-08-12 without using the two-deputy rule (ARC-014, ARC-001).","Treat Elena Ortega's approval of the numeric T-9 results table as approval of PSN-17 prose or any corrected replacement (ARC-016).","Treat Jonah Kim's partial review as final approval of the current drafted full note without his review of replacement text removing C3 and C4 (ARC-015).","Publish with only one deputy's approval while the chair is unavailable (ARC-001 requires both deputies).","Name any organization as production-ready without that organization's explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope (ARC-018).","Invent or assume unrecorded approvals, readiness statements, or FIELD-31 closure."],"material_unknowns":["Whether and when Elena Ortega will approve any specific corrected full-note text (ARC-016 records non-approval only).","Whether Jonah Kim's post-rewrite approval will match ARC-019 wording or require further edits (ARC-015 conditions approval on seeing replacement text).","Whether dual-deputy approval can be completed before Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 versus the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017).","Identity and written positions of any fifth organization implied by C4 beyond Meridian, Bluefield, Kestrel, and Delta as reflected in ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, and ARC-012.","Timeline and outcome for closing FIELD-31 and any re-run that would be needed before future F-4 stability claims (ARC-006, ARC-011)."]}