Phase 2 · open only after BASELINE COMMITTED is visible
Independent Team Evidence Pack
This is one browser-readable projection of the canonical public artifacts. It contains the answer-bearing evidence for the synthetic decision. If you saw this before committing the baseline, report the run as contaminated.
Evaluation law: verify every material worker citation against the full source universe; preserve disagreement; keep evidence, recommendation, authority, and authorization separate.
How to use this pack
The executive brief is repeated only so you can bind the revision to the same before-state. The next six artifacts show each worker's sealed source view and output. The full task lets you verify them. The board composes positions without becoming authority. The receipt documents—but does not independently certify—the worker isolation.
1. Baseline executive brief
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 c9e7ba9dd26a3180ca6924749043e99f567f7424fba1913ef70a945e3730928d
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.executive-brief/v1",
"brief_id": "arcadia-psn-17-executive-brief-v1",
"title": "Tuesday publication decision",
"world": "Arcadia Open Systems Working Group (synthetic)",
"as_of": "2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00",
"decision_question": "Should Arcadia publish PSN-17 as drafted on Tuesday, rewrite it and hold for valid sign-off, or not publish it?",
"allowed_action_classes": [
"publish-as-drafted",
"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"do-not-publish"
],
"draft_claims": [
{"claim_id":"C1","text":"Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs."},
{"claim_id":"C2","text":"No open safety blocker remains for the lab path."},
{"claim_id":"C3","text":"Field path F-4 is stable and ready for public reference."},
{"claim_id":"C4","text":"Five participating organizations have confirmed production readiness."}
],
"prepared_by": "Communications editor",
"packet_status": "final-for-decision",
"recommendation": "Publish PSN-17 as drafted in the Tuesday 09:00 public slot.",
"management_summary": [
"Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs and the lab blocker is closed.",
"The circulated field-status summary marks F-4 green and ready for public reference.",
"Follow-up with all five participating organizations is complete; the editor records the group as production ready.",
"The chair delegated the public-note review while unavailable, and the editor records both deputies as having cleared the exact PSN-17 text.",
"The Tuesday 09:00 publication slot is reserved. The editor recommends releasing PSN-17 without further changes."
],
"reported_checks": {
"latest_status_used": true,
"participant_entities_verified": true,
"production_readiness_replies_verified": true,
"exact_public_text_approved_by_both_deputies": true,
"open_conflicts": 0
},
"ordinary_reliance_rule": "A final-for-decision packet may be used for the decision unless it contains a visible contradiction. Do not assume favorable or unfavorable hidden evidence.",
"baseline_instruction": "Act as the decision maker relying on this ordinary final-for-decision packet. Choose one allowed action class and commit claim dispositions, authority status, material unknowns, confidence, and any investigation you still require before opening the Cellara team.",
"honesty_boundary": "This is a plausible synthetic executive recommendation, including the editor's recorded checks. Its underlying source records are withheld from the baseline so the test can measure whether independent source work changes reliance on a seemingly complete decision packet."
}
2. Investigator sealed source view
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 23d48f7f56a574500396acaad4d241147a6acf5e160b6b72edd396e165a5ee6f
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.worker-input/v1",
"task_id": "arcadia-psn-17-2026-08-10",
"role": "investigator",
"title": "Should Arcadia publish Public Status Note PSN-17 on Tuesday?",
"world": {
"name": "Arcadia Open Systems Working Group",
"kind": "synthetic-public-collaboration",
"description": "A fictional multi-organization working group. Every person, organization, event, and record in this pack is synthetic."
},
"as_of": "2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00",
"decision": {
"question": "Should Arcadia publish PSN-17 as drafted on Tuesday, rewrite it and hold for valid sign-off, or not publish it?",
"allowed_action_classes": [
"publish-as-drafted",
"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"do-not-publish"
],
"must_report": [
"action class",
"claim-by-claim decision",
"authority path",
"material unknowns",
"source ids used"
]
},
"draft_note": {
"id": "PSN-17",
"planned_publication": "2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00",
"claims": [
{
"claim_id": "C1",
"text": "Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs."
},
{
"claim_id": "C2",
"text": "No open safety blocker remains for the lab path."
},
{
"claim_id": "C3",
"text": "Field path F-4 is stable and ready for public reference."
},
{
"claim_id": "C4",
"text": "Five participating organizations have confirmed production readiness."
}
]
},
"selected_source_ids": [
"ARC-001",
"ARC-002",
"ARC-003",
"ARC-004",
"ARC-005",
"ARC-006",
"ARC-007",
"ARC-008",
"ARC-009",
"ARC-010",
"ARC-011",
"ARC-012",
"ARC-014",
"ARC-015",
"ARC-016",
"ARC-018",
"ARC-020",
"ARC-021",
"ARC-024",
"ARC-029",
"ARC-035",
"ARC-042"
],
"selected_source_count": 22,
"full_source_count": 48,
"source_records": [
{
"id": "ARC-001",
"kind": "working-group-charter",
"recorded_at": "2026-05-04T10:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Public statement authority",
"content": "A public status note requires approval from chair Mira Solano or, when she is unavailable, both deputies: Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega. Technical expertise alone does not authorize publication."
},
{
"id": "ARC-002",
"kind": "trial-plan",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-15T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 planned runs",
"content": "Trial T-9 schedules 12 interoperability runs: eight lab-path runs and four field-path runs. Completion means the run executed and produced a recorded result; it does not mean the result was successful."
},
{
"id": "ARC-003",
"kind": "run-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T18:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 final register",
"content": "All 12 planned T-9 runs executed and have result records. Lab: eight completed, eight passed. Field: four completed, three passed, one failed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-004",
"kind": "lab-safety-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T09:15:00-07:00",
"subject": "Lab blocker disposition",
"content": "LAB-22 is closed after the containment rerun. No open safety blocker remains for the lab path as configured in T-9. This disposition does not cover field path F-4."
},
{
"id": "ARC-005",
"kind": "field-run-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-06T12:05:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 preliminary green",
"content": "The first F-4 pass completed without the relay fault. Preliminary status is green pending the final stress sequence."
},
{
"id": "ARC-006",
"kind": "field-incident",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T17:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 final stress failure",
"content": "The final F-4 stress run reproduced relay loss under retry. FIELD-31 is open and blocks describing F-4 as stable or production-ready.",
"supersedes": [
"ARC-005"
]
},
{
"id": "ARC-007",
"kind": "participant-roster",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-20T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 participating organizations",
"content": "The five participating organizations are Meridian Institute, Bluefield Devices, Northstar Systems LLC, Kestrel Operations, and Delta Civic Lab. Northstar Labs Inc. is a separate organization and is not a T-9 participant."
},
{
"id": "ARC-008",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T10:22:00-07:00",
"subject": "Meridian confirmation",
"content": "Meridian confirms its lab adapter completed T-9. It has not evaluated production deployment and is not confirming production readiness."
},
{
"id": "ARC-009",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:04:00-07:00",
"subject": "Bluefield confirmation",
"content": "Bluefield confirms lab-path interoperability only. Its field gateway is outside this trial and no production-readiness statement is approved."
},
{
"id": "ARC-010",
"kind": "external-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:37:00-07:00",
"subject": "Northstar congratulations",
"content": "A director at Northstar Labs Inc. congratulated Arcadia on completing the trial and wrote that the result 'looks production ready.' Northstar Labs Inc. is not Northstar Systems LLC and did not participate in T-9."
},
{
"id": "ARC-011",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T13:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Kestrel position",
"content": "Kestrel says it will not assess production readiness until FIELD-31 is resolved and another F-4 stress run passes."
},
{
"id": "ARC-012",
"kind": "participant-log",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Delta response status",
"content": "Delta Civic Lab has acknowledged receipt of the result packet but has not sent a readiness statement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-014",
"kind": "chair-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-07T16:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Mira Solano availability",
"content": "Chair Mira Solano is unavailable from Monday August 10 through Wednesday August 12 and has delegated urgent public-note approval only through the charter's existing two-deputy rule."
},
{
"id": "ARC-015",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T10:35:00-07:00",
"subject": "Jonah Kim review of PSN-17",
"content": "Jonah approves retaining C1 and the lab-scoped C2. He requests removal of C3 and C4. He will approve a corrected full note after seeing the replacement text."
},
{
"id": "ARC-016",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T11:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Elena Ortega review status",
"content": "Elena approved the numeric T-9 results table. She has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-018",
"kind": "communications-policy",
"recorded_at": "2026-06-02T09:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Named organization claims",
"content": "A public note may name an organization as production-ready only when that organization provides an explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope. Silence, participation, and third-party praise do not count."
},
{
"id": "ARC-020",
"kind": "risk-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Current release risk",
"content": "Publishing C3 or C4 without correction is classified as a material accuracy failure. Publishing C1 and the lab-scoped C2 after valid sign-off is allowed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-021",
"kind": "meeting-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-01T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "June minutes formatting",
"content": "The working group adopted a shorter heading format for monthly meeting minutes."
},
{
"id": "ARC-024",
"kind": "finance-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-08T15:05:00-07:00",
"subject": "Travel stipends",
"content": "July travel stipends were issued to four workshop presenters."
},
{
"id": "ARC-029",
"kind": "research-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-21T09:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "Survey response count",
"content": "Thirty-two people completed the unrelated developer-experience survey."
},
{
"id": "ARC-035",
"kind": "operations-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-01T11:05:00-07:00",
"subject": "Workshop Wi-Fi",
"content": "The venue added a second guest Wi-Fi network for the workshop."
},
{
"id": "ARC-042",
"kind": "people-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-06T17:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Volunteer onboarding",
"content": "Seven volunteers completed community-moderation onboarding."
}
],
"isolation_boundary": "This role sees this materialized source view and its role prompt only. It does not see the evaluator baseline or another worker output."
}
3. Investigator sealed output
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 8bbd85f5a68e79cd882dbcdf813acb67f0350ee23d8742c3a86dd99027b21c03
{"role":"investigator","findings":[{"claim_id":"C1","status":"supported","basis":["ARC-002","ARC-003"],"reason":"ARC-002 defines T-9 completion as execution of all 12 planned runs with recorded results, not success of those results. ARC-003 states all 12 planned T-9 runs executed and have result records (lab 8/8 completed; field 4/4 completed, with one field failure).","caveat":"ARC-003 also records one failed field run; completion under ARC-002 is not equivalent to all runs passing."},{"claim_id":"C2","status":"supported","basis":["ARC-004"],"reason":"ARC-004 closes LAB-22 after the containment rerun and states no open safety blocker remains for the lab path as configured in T-9.","caveat":"ARC-004 explicitly does not cover field path F-4; the claim text is lab-path-scoped only."},{"claim_id":"C3","status":"contradicted","basis":["ARC-003","ARC-005","ARC-006","ARC-011"],"reason":"ARC-006 supersedes ARC-005's preliminary F-4 green: the final F-4 stress run reproduced relay loss, FIELD-31 is open, and ARC-006 blocks describing F-4 as stable or production-ready. ARC-003 records one failed field run. ARC-011 ties participant production assessment to FIELD-31 resolution and another passing F-4 stress run.","caveat":"ARC-005 is superseded and must not be treated as current F-4 status."},{"claim_id":"C4","status":"contradicted","basis":["ARC-007","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-010","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-018"],"reason":"ARC-007 names five T-9 participants: Meridian Institute, Bluefield Devices, Northstar Systems LLC, Kestrel Operations, and Delta Civic Lab; Northstar Labs Inc. is a separate non-participant. ARC-018 requires each named organization's explicit written production-readiness statement for the exact deployment scope; silence, participation, and third-party praise do not count. ARC-008 Meridian completed lab adapter work and is not confirming production readiness. ARC-009 Bluefield confirms lab-path interoperability only and approves no production-readiness statement. ARC-011 Kestrel will not assess production readiness until FIELD-31 is resolved and another F-4 stress run passes. ARC-012 Delta acknowledged the result packet but sent no readiness statement. ARC-010 is third-party praise from non-participant Northstar Labs Inc., not a participant confirmation.","caveat":"Selected sources contain no production-readiness statement from actual participant Northstar Systems LLC; that absence is an unknown for that org but does not repair the claim that all five confirmed readiness."}],"authority_findings":[{"status":"chair-unavailable-delegated-to-two-deputy-rule","basis":["ARC-001","ARC-014"],"reason":"ARC-001 requires public status note approval from chair Mira Solano or, if unavailable, both deputies Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega; technical expertise alone does not authorize publication. ARC-014 states Mira is unavailable 2026-08-10 through 2026-08-12 and may approve urgent public notes only via that existing two-deputy rule."},{"status":"dual-deputy-approval-not-met-for-PSN-17-as-drafted","basis":["ARC-001","ARC-015","ARC-016"],"reason":"ARC-015: Jonah retains C1 and lab-scoped C2, requests removal of C3 and C4, and will approve a corrected full note only after seeing replacement text—so he has not approved PSN-17 as drafted with C3/C4. ARC-016: Elena approved only the numeric T-9 results table and has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement. Under ARC-001 both deputies are required while the chair is unavailable; that joint approval path for the drafted note is incomplete."},{"status":"risk-register-limits-publishable-content","basis":["ARC-020"],"reason":"ARC-020 classifies publishing C3 or C4 without correction as a material accuracy failure, and allows publishing C1 and lab-scoped C2 only after valid sign-off—which is not present for the full drafted note."}],"material_unknowns":["No selected-source production-readiness statement from participant Northstar Systems LLC (distinct from non-participant Northstar Labs Inc. in ARC-007/ARC-010).","Elena Ortega's approval or rejection of any corrected PSN-17 prose is unknown; ARC-016 covers only the numeric results table.","Jonah Kim's post-correction full-note approval is contingent on replacement text not present in the pack (ARC-015).","Whether both deputies will complete dual approval before planned publication 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 while Mira remains unavailable through 2026-08-12 (ARC-014) is unknown."],"discarded_distractors":[{"id":"ARC-010","reason":"Alias/org confusion: Northstar Labs Inc. praise is not a T-9 participant confirmation and is not Northstar Systems LLC (ARC-007, ARC-018)."},{"id":"ARC-005","reason":"Superseded preliminary F-4 green; current field status is ARC-006."},{"id":"ARC-021","reason":"Unrelated June minutes formatting."},{"id":"ARC-024","reason":"Unrelated travel stipends."},{"id":"ARC-029","reason":"Unrelated developer-experience survey count."},{"id":"ARC-035","reason":"Unrelated workshop Wi-Fi."},{"id":"ARC-042","reason":"Unrelated volunteer onboarding."}]}
4. Critic sealed source view
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 b99603315502f49e5ae694298278e5f82fb5874e8f97786de718e4841f1c783b
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.worker-input/v1",
"task_id": "arcadia-psn-17-2026-08-10",
"role": "critic",
"title": "Should Arcadia publish Public Status Note PSN-17 on Tuesday?",
"world": {
"name": "Arcadia Open Systems Working Group",
"kind": "synthetic-public-collaboration",
"description": "A fictional multi-organization working group. Every person, organization, event, and record in this pack is synthetic."
},
"as_of": "2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00",
"decision": {
"question": "Should Arcadia publish PSN-17 as drafted on Tuesday, rewrite it and hold for valid sign-off, or not publish it?",
"allowed_action_classes": [
"publish-as-drafted",
"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"do-not-publish"
],
"must_report": [
"action class",
"claim-by-claim decision",
"authority path",
"material unknowns",
"source ids used"
]
},
"draft_note": {
"id": "PSN-17",
"planned_publication": "2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00",
"claims": [
{
"claim_id": "C1",
"text": "Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs."
},
{
"claim_id": "C2",
"text": "No open safety blocker remains for the lab path."
},
{
"claim_id": "C3",
"text": "Field path F-4 is stable and ready for public reference."
},
{
"claim_id": "C4",
"text": "Five participating organizations have confirmed production readiness."
}
]
},
"selected_source_ids": [
"ARC-002",
"ARC-003",
"ARC-004",
"ARC-005",
"ARC-006",
"ARC-007",
"ARC-008",
"ARC-009",
"ARC-010",
"ARC-011",
"ARC-012",
"ARC-013",
"ARC-015",
"ARC-016",
"ARC-017",
"ARC-018",
"ARC-020",
"ARC-023",
"ARC-027",
"ARC-031",
"ARC-036",
"ARC-045"
],
"selected_source_count": 22,
"full_source_count": 48,
"source_records": [
{
"id": "ARC-002",
"kind": "trial-plan",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-15T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 planned runs",
"content": "Trial T-9 schedules 12 interoperability runs: eight lab-path runs and four field-path runs. Completion means the run executed and produced a recorded result; it does not mean the result was successful."
},
{
"id": "ARC-003",
"kind": "run-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T18:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 final register",
"content": "All 12 planned T-9 runs executed and have result records. Lab: eight completed, eight passed. Field: four completed, three passed, one failed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-004",
"kind": "lab-safety-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T09:15:00-07:00",
"subject": "Lab blocker disposition",
"content": "LAB-22 is closed after the containment rerun. No open safety blocker remains for the lab path as configured in T-9. This disposition does not cover field path F-4."
},
{
"id": "ARC-005",
"kind": "field-run-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-06T12:05:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 preliminary green",
"content": "The first F-4 pass completed without the relay fault. Preliminary status is green pending the final stress sequence."
},
{
"id": "ARC-006",
"kind": "field-incident",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T17:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 final stress failure",
"content": "The final F-4 stress run reproduced relay loss under retry. FIELD-31 is open and blocks describing F-4 as stable or production-ready.",
"supersedes": [
"ARC-005"
]
},
{
"id": "ARC-007",
"kind": "participant-roster",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-20T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 participating organizations",
"content": "The five participating organizations are Meridian Institute, Bluefield Devices, Northstar Systems LLC, Kestrel Operations, and Delta Civic Lab. Northstar Labs Inc. is a separate organization and is not a T-9 participant."
},
{
"id": "ARC-008",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T10:22:00-07:00",
"subject": "Meridian confirmation",
"content": "Meridian confirms its lab adapter completed T-9. It has not evaluated production deployment and is not confirming production readiness."
},
{
"id": "ARC-009",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:04:00-07:00",
"subject": "Bluefield confirmation",
"content": "Bluefield confirms lab-path interoperability only. Its field gateway is outside this trial and no production-readiness statement is approved."
},
{
"id": "ARC-010",
"kind": "external-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:37:00-07:00",
"subject": "Northstar congratulations",
"content": "A director at Northstar Labs Inc. congratulated Arcadia on completing the trial and wrote that the result 'looks production ready.' Northstar Labs Inc. is not Northstar Systems LLC and did not participate in T-9."
},
{
"id": "ARC-011",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T13:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Kestrel position",
"content": "Kestrel says it will not assess production readiness until FIELD-31 is resolved and another F-4 stress run passes."
},
{
"id": "ARC-012",
"kind": "participant-log",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Delta response status",
"content": "Delta Civic Lab has acknowledged receipt of the result packet but has not sent a readiness statement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-013",
"kind": "editor-draft",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T15:20:00-07:00",
"subject": "PSN-17 draft basis",
"content": "The editor derived C4 by counting the five roster organizations, treating any positive or absent response as confirmation. The editor used the preliminary F-4 green note for C3 and had not seen the final incident."
},
{
"id": "ARC-015",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T10:35:00-07:00",
"subject": "Jonah Kim review of PSN-17",
"content": "Jonah approves retaining C1 and the lab-scoped C2. He requests removal of C3 and C4. He will approve a corrected full note after seeing the replacement text."
},
{
"id": "ARC-016",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T11:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Elena Ortega review status",
"content": "Elena approved the numeric T-9 results table. She has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-017",
"kind": "release-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T12:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Tuesday publication slot",
"content": "The Tuesday 9:00 AM publication slot is optional. Missing it has no contractual or safety consequence; the next ordinary slot is Thursday."
},
{
"id": "ARC-018",
"kind": "communications-policy",
"recorded_at": "2026-06-02T09:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Named organization claims",
"content": "A public note may name an organization as production-ready only when that organization provides an explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope. Silence, participation, and third-party praise do not count."
},
{
"id": "ARC-020",
"kind": "risk-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Current release risk",
"content": "Publishing C3 or C4 without correction is classified as a material accuracy failure. Publishing C1 and the lab-scoped C2 after valid sign-off is allowed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-023",
"kind": "documentation-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-06T11:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Glossary sort order",
"content": "The protocol glossary now sorts aliases after canonical terms."
},
{
"id": "ARC-027",
"kind": "documentation-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-16T08:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "Diagram colors",
"content": "Architecture diagrams now use patterns as well as color."
},
{
"id": "ARC-031",
"kind": "vendor-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-24T15:50:00-07:00",
"subject": "Video archive",
"content": "The video archive vendor extended retention to eighteen months."
},
{
"id": "ARC-036",
"kind": "finance-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-02T16:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Printing invoice",
"content": "The July printing invoice was approved with no exceptions."
},
{
"id": "ARC-045",
"kind": "community-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T08:25:00-07:00",
"subject": "Forum tag cleanup",
"content": "Duplicate help tags were merged in the community forum."
}
],
"isolation_boundary": "This role sees this materialized source view and its role prompt only. It does not see the evaluator baseline or another worker output."
}
5. Critic sealed output
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 862b08c33b9a39e03b4c1f0d1960671460c22c847de218d15f40b4eb4d4c267d
{"role":"critic","challenges":[{"challenge_id":"CH-C3-STALE","target":"C3","severity":"critical","basis":["ARC-005","ARC-006","ARC-013","ARC-020"],"reason":"C3 asserts F-4 is stable and ready for public reference, but ARC-006 records final stress failure, open FIELD-31, and an explicit ban on calling F-4 stable or production-ready; ARC-006 supersedes ARC-005's preliminary green. ARC-013 shows the draft was built on the superseded preliminary note. ARC-020 classifies uncorrected C3 as a material accuracy failure.","required_correction":"Delete C3, or replace it with a statement that F-4 failed final stress, FIELD-31 is open, and F-4 must not be described as stable or production-ready (ARC-006)."},{"challenge_id":"CH-C4-OVERCLAIM","target":"C4","severity":"critical","basis":["ARC-007","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-013","ARC-018","ARC-020"],"reason":"C4 claims five organizations confirmed production readiness. ARC-008 Meridian and ARC-009 Bluefield explicitly refuse production-readiness confirmation; ARC-011 Kestrel withholds assessment until FIELD-31 is resolved; ARC-012 Delta sent no readiness statement. ARC-013 admits the editor counted roster membership and treated positive or absent responses as confirmation. ARC-018 forbids counting silence, participation, or third-party praise as readiness. ARC-020 classifies uncorrected C4 as a material accuracy failure.","required_correction":"Delete C4, or restate only organizations with explicit written production-readiness statements for the exact deployment scope per ARC-018; current evidence supports zero such confirmations among participants."},{"challenge_id":"CH-C4-ENTITY","target":"C4","severity":"critical","basis":["ARC-007","ARC-010","ARC-018"],"reason":"Entity confusion risk: ARC-010 Northstar Labs Inc. praise ('looks production ready') is from a non-participant and is not Northstar Systems LLC (ARC-007). Using that praise to support a five-org production-readiness claim would launder a third-party outsider into participant confirmation, which ARC-018 rejects.","required_correction":"Exclude Northstar Labs Inc. entirely from any participant readiness count; never equate outsider congratulations with participant confirmation."},{"challenge_id":"CH-C1-SCOPE","target":"C1","severity":"moderate","basis":["ARC-002","ARC-003"],"reason":"C1's wording 'completed all 12 planned interoperability runs' is only safe under ARC-002's narrow definition (executed with a recorded result, not success). ARC-003 shows one field run failed. Without that definitional limit, C1 scope-launders execution completion into implied trial success.","required_correction":"If retained, state explicitly that all 12 runs executed with recorded results, including three field passes and one field failure (ARC-003), and do not imply overall success."},{"challenge_id":"CH-C2-BOUNDARY","target":"C2","severity":"moderate","basis":["ARC-004","ARC-006"],"reason":"C2 is supportable only as lab-path-as-configured-in-T-9 (ARC-004). Unqualified public wording can scope-launder lab clearance over field path F-4, which ARC-004 explicitly excludes and which still has open FIELD-31 (ARC-006).","required_correction":"If retained, bind C2 strictly to the lab path as configured in T-9 and state that field path F-4 is out of scope for this disposition."},{"challenge_id":"CH-AUTHORITY-DRAFT","target":"PSN-17 as drafted","severity":"critical","basis":["ARC-015","ARC-016","ARC-017","ARC-020"],"reason":"No valid authority path supports publish-as-drafted. ARC-015 Jonah retains only C1 and lab-scoped C2 and requires removal of C3 and C4, with full-note approval only after seeing replacement text. ARC-016 Elena approved a numeric results table only, not PSN-17 prose or any corrected replacement. ARC-017 makes the Tuesday slot optional with no contractual or safety consequence. ARC-020 forbids publishing C3 or C4 without correction.","required_correction":"Do not publish as drafted. Hold for rewrite that removes or corrects C3 and C4, then obtain explicit approval of the replacement full note text from the required reviewers before any release."}],"false_comforts":["Reading C1 'completed' as if all planned runs succeeded rather than merely executed (ARC-002, ARC-003).","Relying on ARC-005 preliminary F-4 green after ARC-006 superseded it and opened FIELD-31.","Treating ARC-010 Northstar Labs Inc. congratulations as participant production-readiness evidence.","Treating roster membership, silence, lab-only confirmations, or absent responses as production-readiness confirmation (ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, ARC-012, ARC-013, ARC-018).","Treating Elena's numeric table approval as approval of PSN-17 prose (ARC-016).","Treating the Tuesday 09:00 slot as a forcing deadline despite ARC-017 saying it is optional and without contractual or safety consequence.","Assuming Jonah's conditional path (retain C1/lab C2; remove C3/C4; approve after replacement text) already authorizes the current draft (ARC-015)."],"authority_challenges":["Jonah Kim (ARC-015) has not approved the drafted full note; he withholds approval of C3 and C4 and requires replacement text before approving a corrected full note.","Elena Ortega (ARC-016) has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement—only a numeric T-9 results table.","No source in this view records dual or full communications sign-off of the drafted PSN-17 claims as a package.","ARC-018 blocks naming organizations production-ready without explicit written readiness for exact deployment scope; the draft's C4 has no such authority chain.","ARC-020 authorizes only C1 and lab-scoped C2 after valid sign-off; it classifies uncorrected C3/C4 publication as material accuracy failure.","Calendar pressure cannot manufacture authority: ARC-017 states missing Tuesday has no contractual or safety consequence."],"residual_unknowns":["Which exact officer set must jointly approve a corrected full public note before release is not fully specified in the selected sources (only Jonah's conditional path and Elena's non-approval of prose appear).","Whether Northstar Systems LLC (actual participant per ARC-007) ever sent any readiness or result statement is not present in this view.","Whether any participant later provided an explicit written production-readiness statement after the timestamps in ARC-008 through ARC-012 is unknown as of 2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00.","This role sees 22 of 48 sources; additional sign-off, supersession, or risk records outside selected_source_ids are unknown and cannot be assumed favorable.","Exact public wording that would satisfy Jonah's 'replacement text' requirement (ARC-015) is not yet fixed in the record."]}
6. Planner sealed source view
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 d7971a11c098d9e6e073a21a9254d335c125ac225403aea62d896f8aa515ba3c
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.worker-input/v1",
"task_id": "arcadia-psn-17-2026-08-10",
"role": "planner",
"title": "Should Arcadia publish Public Status Note PSN-17 on Tuesday?",
"world": {
"name": "Arcadia Open Systems Working Group",
"kind": "synthetic-public-collaboration",
"description": "A fictional multi-organization working group. Every person, organization, event, and record in this pack is synthetic."
},
"as_of": "2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00",
"decision": {
"question": "Should Arcadia publish PSN-17 as drafted on Tuesday, rewrite it and hold for valid sign-off, or not publish it?",
"allowed_action_classes": [
"publish-as-drafted",
"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"do-not-publish"
],
"must_report": [
"action class",
"claim-by-claim decision",
"authority path",
"material unknowns",
"source ids used"
]
},
"draft_note": {
"id": "PSN-17",
"planned_publication": "2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00",
"claims": [
{
"claim_id": "C1",
"text": "Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs."
},
{
"claim_id": "C2",
"text": "No open safety blocker remains for the lab path."
},
{
"claim_id": "C3",
"text": "Field path F-4 is stable and ready for public reference."
},
{
"claim_id": "C4",
"text": "Five participating organizations have confirmed production readiness."
}
]
},
"selected_source_ids": [
"ARC-001",
"ARC-002",
"ARC-003",
"ARC-004",
"ARC-006",
"ARC-008",
"ARC-009",
"ARC-011",
"ARC-012",
"ARC-014",
"ARC-015",
"ARC-016",
"ARC-017",
"ARC-018",
"ARC-019",
"ARC-020",
"ARC-025",
"ARC-030",
"ARC-037",
"ARC-040",
"ARC-043",
"ARC-048"
],
"selected_source_count": 22,
"full_source_count": 48,
"source_records": [
{
"id": "ARC-001",
"kind": "working-group-charter",
"recorded_at": "2026-05-04T10:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Public statement authority",
"content": "A public status note requires approval from chair Mira Solano or, when she is unavailable, both deputies: Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega. Technical expertise alone does not authorize publication."
},
{
"id": "ARC-002",
"kind": "trial-plan",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-15T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 planned runs",
"content": "Trial T-9 schedules 12 interoperability runs: eight lab-path runs and four field-path runs. Completion means the run executed and produced a recorded result; it does not mean the result was successful."
},
{
"id": "ARC-003",
"kind": "run-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T18:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 final register",
"content": "All 12 planned T-9 runs executed and have result records. Lab: eight completed, eight passed. Field: four completed, three passed, one failed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-004",
"kind": "lab-safety-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T09:15:00-07:00",
"subject": "Lab blocker disposition",
"content": "LAB-22 is closed after the containment rerun. No open safety blocker remains for the lab path as configured in T-9. This disposition does not cover field path F-4."
},
{
"id": "ARC-006",
"kind": "field-incident",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T17:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 final stress failure",
"content": "The final F-4 stress run reproduced relay loss under retry. FIELD-31 is open and blocks describing F-4 as stable or production-ready.",
"supersedes": [
"ARC-005"
]
},
{
"id": "ARC-008",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T10:22:00-07:00",
"subject": "Meridian confirmation",
"content": "Meridian confirms its lab adapter completed T-9. It has not evaluated production deployment and is not confirming production readiness."
},
{
"id": "ARC-009",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:04:00-07:00",
"subject": "Bluefield confirmation",
"content": "Bluefield confirms lab-path interoperability only. Its field gateway is outside this trial and no production-readiness statement is approved."
},
{
"id": "ARC-011",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T13:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Kestrel position",
"content": "Kestrel says it will not assess production readiness until FIELD-31 is resolved and another F-4 stress run passes."
},
{
"id": "ARC-012",
"kind": "participant-log",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Delta response status",
"content": "Delta Civic Lab has acknowledged receipt of the result packet but has not sent a readiness statement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-014",
"kind": "chair-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-07T16:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Mira Solano availability",
"content": "Chair Mira Solano is unavailable from Monday August 10 through Wednesday August 12 and has delegated urgent public-note approval only through the charter's existing two-deputy rule."
},
{
"id": "ARC-015",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T10:35:00-07:00",
"subject": "Jonah Kim review of PSN-17",
"content": "Jonah approves retaining C1 and the lab-scoped C2. He requests removal of C3 and C4. He will approve a corrected full note after seeing the replacement text."
},
{
"id": "ARC-016",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T11:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Elena Ortega review status",
"content": "Elena approved the numeric T-9 results table. She has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-017",
"kind": "release-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T12:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Tuesday publication slot",
"content": "The Tuesday 9:00 AM publication slot is optional. Missing it has no contractual or safety consequence; the next ordinary slot is Thursday."
},
{
"id": "ARC-018",
"kind": "communications-policy",
"recorded_at": "2026-06-02T09:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Named organization claims",
"content": "A public note may name an organization as production-ready only when that organization provides an explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope. Silence, participation, and third-party praise do not count."
},
{
"id": "ARC-019",
"kind": "working-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T13:20:00-07:00",
"subject": "Candidate corrected note",
"content": "A staff member proposes: 'T-9 completed all 12 planned runs. All eight lab-path runs passed and the lab blocker is closed. One field-path stress run failed; FIELD-31 remains open. Participant production readiness has not been established.' This is draft text, not an approved public note."
},
{
"id": "ARC-020",
"kind": "risk-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Current release risk",
"content": "Publishing C3 or C4 without correction is classified as a material accuracy failure. Publishing C1 and the lab-scoped C2 after valid sign-off is allowed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-025",
"kind": "community-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-10T10:45:00-07:00",
"subject": "Forum migration",
"content": "The community forum archive moved to read-only storage."
},
{
"id": "ARC-030",
"kind": "calendar-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-22T12:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Office hours",
"content": "Community office hours move to Thursdays beginning in September."
},
{
"id": "ARC-037",
"kind": "documentation-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-03T08:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "Sample code license",
"content": "The sample repository footer now names the correct permissive license."
},
{
"id": "ARC-040",
"kind": "meeting-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-05T15:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "Plenary agenda",
"content": "The September plenary agenda reserves twenty minutes for open questions."
},
{
"id": "ARC-043",
"kind": "calendar-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-07T09:50:00-07:00",
"subject": "Demo rehearsal",
"content": "The unrelated September demo rehearsal moved to the afternoon."
},
{
"id": "ARC-048",
"kind": "community-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T14:25:00-07:00",
"subject": "Mentor matching",
"content": "The fall mentor matching form received nineteen submissions."
}
],
"isolation_boundary": "This role sees this materialized source view and its role prompt only. It does not see the evaluator baseline or another worker output."
}
7. Planner sealed output
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 b804fba3695be57207d2c5e7065bbc1b0d703a4cdb5f5633e3fe60dac1032502
{"role":"planner","options":[{"option_id":"O1","action_class":"publish-as-drafted","steps":["Retain PSN-17 claims C1–C4 unchanged for the Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 slot (draft_note.planned_publication).","Treat existing deputy artifacts as sufficient authorization without obtaining a new dual-deputy approval of the full note text."],"authority_required":"Per ARC-001, a public status note requires chair Mira Solano or both deputies Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega. ARC-014 places Mira unavailable through 2026-08-12, so only the two-deputy path is available. ARC-015 is only a partial Jonah review (retain C1 and lab-scoped C2; remove C3 and C4). ARC-016 states Elena has not approved PSN-17 prose. This option lacks recorded dual-deputy approval of the drafted note.","earliest_safe_time":null,"residual_risks":["Material accuracy failure if C3 or C4 publish unchanged (ARC-020); C3 is blocked by open FIELD-31 (ARC-006) after one failed field stress run (ARC-003).","C4 lacks explicit written production-readiness statements (ARC-018); Meridian, Bluefield, Kestrel, and Delta do not supply them (ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, ARC-012).","Publication without valid dual-deputy (or chair) approval violates ARC-001 given Mira's unavailability (ARC-014)."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-003","ARC-006","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-014","ARC-015","ARC-016","ARC-018","ARC-020"]},{"option_id":"O2","action_class":"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff","steps":["Rewrite PSN-17 so it does not assert F-4 stability/public-reference readiness (remove or replace C3) and does not assert five-organization production readiness (remove or replace C4), consistent with ARC-006, ARC-018, ARC-015, and ARC-020.","Keep only source-supported content: C1 as run-completion (all 12 planned runs executed with recorded results per ARC-002 and ARC-003) and lab-scoped C2 (no open lab safety blocker per ARC-004; field not covered).","Use ARC-019 candidate corrected text as a staff draft baseline if desired; treat it as unapproved until signed (ARC-019).","Route the full corrected note to Jonah Kim for approval of the replacement text (ARC-015: he will approve a corrected full note after seeing replacement text).","Route the same full corrected note to Elena Ortega for approval of the note/prose, not merely the numeric T-9 results table (ARC-016).","Publish only after both deputies approve the identical corrected text (ARC-001 two-deputy rule while Mira is unavailable per ARC-014).","If dual-deputy approval is not complete before Tuesday 09:00, skip the optional Tuesday slot and use the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017)."],"authority_required":"Both deputies Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega must approve the corrected full public-note text (ARC-001; ARC-014). Chair path is unavailable through 2026-08-12 (ARC-014). Technical expertise alone does not authorize publication (ARC-001). Jonah's prior partial review is not final until he sees replacement text (ARC-015). Elena's table approval is not note approval (ARC-016).","earliest_safe_time":"After both deputies approve the same corrected note text; no earlier than that dual approval. Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 only if that dual approval is recorded before the slot; otherwise the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017).","residual_risks":["Elena may withhold or condition approval of corrected prose (status unknown beyond ARC-016).","Any rewrite that reintroduces C3/C4-class assertions would re-trigger material accuracy failure (ARC-020).","FIELD-31 remains open (ARC-006), so residual field-path risk must stay out of public claims."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-002","ARC-003","ARC-004","ARC-006","ARC-014","ARC-015","ARC-016","ARC-017","ARC-018","ARC-019","ARC-020"]},{"option_id":"O3","action_class":"do-not-publish","steps":["Do not publish PSN-17 in any form in the Tuesday slot or later ordinary slots until leadership reopens the question.","Leave C3/C4-class claims unpublished given open FIELD-31 and missing readiness statements (ARC-006, ARC-018, ARC-020).","Accept that missing Tuesday has no contractual or safety consequence (ARC-017)."],"authority_required":"No public-note authority exercise is required to withhold publication. Any later publication still needs chair or both deputies per ARC-001.","earliest_safe_time":null,"residual_risks":["Withholds even the source-supported C1 and lab-scoped C2 content that ARC-020 says may publish after valid sign-off.","Does not clear FIELD-31 or obtain participant readiness statements if a future note is desired (ARC-006, ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, ARC-012)."],"basis":["ARC-001","ARC-006","ARC-008","ARC-009","ARC-011","ARC-012","ARC-017","ARC-018","ARC-020"]}],"recommended_option_id":"O2","forbidden_actions":["Publish PSN-17 as drafted with C3 and/or C4 unchanged (material accuracy failure per ARC-020; C3 blocked by ARC-006/ARC-003; C4 blocked by ARC-018 and ARC-008/ARC-009/ARC-011/ARC-012).","Publish on chair authority while Mira Solano is unavailable 2026-08-10 through 2026-08-12 without using the two-deputy rule (ARC-014, ARC-001).","Treat Elena Ortega's approval of the numeric T-9 results table as approval of PSN-17 prose or any corrected replacement (ARC-016).","Treat Jonah Kim's partial review as final approval of the current drafted full note without his review of replacement text removing C3 and C4 (ARC-015).","Publish with only one deputy's approval while the chair is unavailable (ARC-001 requires both deputies).","Name any organization as production-ready without that organization's explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope (ARC-018).","Invent or assume unrecorded approvals, readiness statements, or FIELD-31 closure."],"material_unknowns":["Whether and when Elena Ortega will approve any specific corrected full-note text (ARC-016 records non-approval only).","Whether Jonah Kim's post-rewrite approval will match ARC-019 wording or require further edits (ARC-015 conditions approval on seeing replacement text).","Whether dual-deputy approval can be completed before Tuesday 2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00 versus the next ordinary Thursday slot (ARC-017).","Identity and written positions of any fifth organization implied by C4 beyond Meridian, Bluefield, Kestrel, and Delta as reflected in ARC-008, ARC-009, ARC-011, and ARC-012.","Timeline and outcome for closing FIELD-31 and any re-run that would be needed before future F-4 stability claims (ARC-006, ARC-011)."]}
8. Full 48-record source universe
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 6a70f95ebaa1fb2b546530ab82fcb41f77e671fc8572eede540b196c38172561
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.task/v1",
"task_id": "arcadia-psn-17-2026-08-10",
"title": "Should Arcadia publish Public Status Note PSN-17 on Tuesday?",
"world": {
"name": "Arcadia Open Systems Working Group",
"kind": "synthetic-public-collaboration",
"description": "A fictional multi-organization working group. Every person, organization, event, and record in this pack is synthetic."
},
"as_of": "2026-08-10T16:00:00-07:00",
"decision": {
"question": "Should Arcadia publish PSN-17 as drafted on Tuesday, rewrite it and hold for valid sign-off, or not publish it?",
"allowed_action_classes": [
"publish-as-drafted",
"rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"do-not-publish"
],
"must_report": [
"action class",
"claim-by-claim decision",
"authority path",
"material unknowns",
"source ids used"
]
},
"draft_note": {
"id": "PSN-17",
"planned_publication": "2026-08-11T09:00:00-07:00",
"claims": [
{
"claim_id": "C1",
"text": "Trial T-9 completed all 12 planned interoperability runs."
},
{
"claim_id": "C2",
"text": "No open safety blocker remains for the lab path."
},
{
"claim_id": "C3",
"text": "Field path F-4 is stable and ready for public reference."
},
{
"claim_id": "C4",
"text": "Five participating organizations have confirmed production readiness."
}
]
},
"baseline_rule": "Use only this task file. Commit your own decision before opening any worker or team-board artifact.",
"source_records": [
{
"id": "ARC-001",
"kind": "working-group-charter",
"recorded_at": "2026-05-04T10:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Public statement authority",
"content": "A public status note requires approval from chair Mira Solano or, when she is unavailable, both deputies: Jonah Kim and Elena Ortega. Technical expertise alone does not authorize publication."
},
{
"id": "ARC-002",
"kind": "trial-plan",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-15T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 planned runs",
"content": "Trial T-9 schedules 12 interoperability runs: eight lab-path runs and four field-path runs. Completion means the run executed and produced a recorded result; it does not mean the result was successful."
},
{
"id": "ARC-003",
"kind": "run-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T18:40:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 final register",
"content": "All 12 planned T-9 runs executed and have result records. Lab: eight completed, eight passed. Field: four completed, three passed, one failed."
},
{
"id": "ARC-004",
"kind": "lab-safety-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T09:15:00-07:00",
"subject": "Lab blocker disposition",
"content": "LAB-22 is closed after the containment rerun. No open safety blocker remains for the lab path as configured in T-9. This disposition does not cover field path F-4."
},
{
"id": "ARC-005",
"kind": "field-run-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-06T12:05:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 preliminary green",
"content": "The first F-4 pass completed without the relay fault. Preliminary status is green pending the final stress sequence."
},
{
"id": "ARC-006",
"kind": "field-incident",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-08T17:55:00-07:00",
"subject": "F-4 final stress failure",
"content": "The final F-4 stress run reproduced relay loss under retry. FIELD-31 is open and blocks describing F-4 as stable or production-ready.",
"supersedes": ["ARC-005"]
},
{
"id": "ARC-007",
"kind": "participant-roster",
"recorded_at": "2026-07-20T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "T-9 participating organizations",
"content": "The five participating organizations are Meridian Institute, Bluefield Devices, Northstar Systems LLC, Kestrel Operations, and Delta Civic Lab. Northstar Labs Inc. is a separate organization and is not a T-9 participant."
},
{
"id": "ARC-008",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T10:22:00-07:00",
"subject": "Meridian confirmation",
"content": "Meridian confirms its lab adapter completed T-9. It has not evaluated production deployment and is not confirming production readiness."
},
{
"id": "ARC-009",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:04:00-07:00",
"subject": "Bluefield confirmation",
"content": "Bluefield confirms lab-path interoperability only. Its field gateway is outside this trial and no production-readiness statement is approved."
},
{
"id": "ARC-010",
"kind": "external-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T11:37:00-07:00",
"subject": "Northstar congratulations",
"content": "A director at Northstar Labs Inc. congratulated Arcadia on completing the trial and wrote that the result 'looks production ready.' Northstar Labs Inc. is not Northstar Systems LLC and did not participate in T-9."
},
{
"id": "ARC-011",
"kind": "participant-email",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T13:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Kestrel position",
"content": "Kestrel says it will not assess production readiness until FIELD-31 is resolved and another F-4 stress run passes."
},
{
"id": "ARC-012",
"kind": "participant-log",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T09:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Delta response status",
"content": "Delta Civic Lab has acknowledged receipt of the result packet but has not sent a readiness statement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-013",
"kind": "editor-draft",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-09T15:20:00-07:00",
"subject": "PSN-17 draft basis",
"content": "The editor derived C4 by counting the five roster organizations, treating any positive or absent response as confirmation. The editor used the preliminary F-4 green note for C3 and had not seen the final incident."
},
{
"id": "ARC-014",
"kind": "chair-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-07T16:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Mira Solano availability",
"content": "Chair Mira Solano is unavailable from Monday August 10 through Wednesday August 12 and has delegated urgent public-note approval only through the charter's existing two-deputy rule."
},
{
"id": "ARC-015",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T10:35:00-07:00",
"subject": "Jonah Kim review of PSN-17",
"content": "Jonah approves retaining C1 and the lab-scoped C2. He requests removal of C3 and C4. He will approve a corrected full note after seeing the replacement text."
},
{
"id": "ARC-016",
"kind": "deputy-review",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T11:10:00-07:00",
"subject": "Elena Ortega review status",
"content": "Elena approved the numeric T-9 results table. She has not approved PSN-17, its prose, or any corrected replacement."
},
{
"id": "ARC-017",
"kind": "release-calendar",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T12:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Tuesday publication slot",
"content": "The Tuesday 9:00 AM publication slot is optional. Missing it has no contractual or safety consequence; the next ordinary slot is Thursday."
},
{
"id": "ARC-018",
"kind": "communications-policy",
"recorded_at": "2026-06-02T09:30:00-07:00",
"subject": "Named organization claims",
"content": "A public note may name an organization as production-ready only when that organization provides an explicit written readiness statement for the exact deployment scope. Silence, participation, and third-party praise do not count."
},
{
"id": "ARC-019",
"kind": "working-note",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T13:20:00-07:00",
"subject": "Candidate corrected note",
"content": "A staff member proposes: 'T-9 completed all 12 planned runs. All eight lab-path runs passed and the lab blocker is closed. One field-path stress run failed; FIELD-31 remains open. Participant production readiness has not been established.' This is draft text, not an approved public note."
},
{
"id": "ARC-020",
"kind": "risk-register",
"recorded_at": "2026-08-10T14:00:00-07:00",
"subject": "Current release risk",
"content": "Publishing C3 or C4 without correction is classified as a material accuracy failure. Publishing C1 and the lab-scoped C2 after valid sign-off is allowed."
},
{"id":"ARC-021","kind":"meeting-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-01T09:00:00-07:00","subject":"June minutes formatting","content":"The working group adopted a shorter heading format for monthly meeting minutes."},
{"id":"ARC-022","kind":"operations-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-03T14:10:00-07:00","subject":"Room booking","content":"The August workshop room booking includes two overflow rooms."},
{"id":"ARC-023","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-06T11:30:00-07:00","subject":"Glossary sort order","content":"The protocol glossary now sorts aliases after canonical terms."},
{"id":"ARC-024","kind":"finance-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-08T15:05:00-07:00","subject":"Travel stipends","content":"July travel stipends were issued to four workshop presenters."},
{"id":"ARC-025","kind":"community-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-10T10:45:00-07:00","subject":"Forum migration","content":"The community forum archive moved to read-only storage."},
{"id":"ARC-026","kind":"meeting-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-13T16:20:00-07:00","subject":"Captioning vendor","content":"Live captioning is confirmed for the September plenary."},
{"id":"ARC-027","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-16T08:55:00-07:00","subject":"Diagram colors","content":"Architecture diagrams now use patterns as well as color."},
{"id":"ARC-028","kind":"operations-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-18T13:35:00-07:00","subject":"Badge printer","content":"The workshop badge printer received a routine maintenance kit."},
{"id":"ARC-029","kind":"research-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-21T09:40:00-07:00","subject":"Survey response count","content":"Thirty-two people completed the unrelated developer-experience survey."},
{"id":"ARC-030","kind":"calendar-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-22T12:10:00-07:00","subject":"Office hours","content":"Community office hours move to Thursdays beginning in September."},
{"id":"ARC-031","kind":"vendor-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-24T15:50:00-07:00","subject":"Video archive","content":"The video archive vendor extended retention to eighteen months."},
{"id":"ARC-032","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-27T10:15:00-07:00","subject":"Broken links","content":"Six obsolete links were removed from the getting-started guide."},
{"id":"ARC-033","kind":"people-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-28T14:45:00-07:00","subject":"Moderator rotation","content":"The August forum moderator rotation was published."},
{"id":"ARC-034","kind":"community-note","recorded_at":"2026-07-30T09:25:00-07:00","subject":"Newsletter cadence","content":"The community newsletter will remain monthly through year end."},
{"id":"ARC-035","kind":"operations-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-01T11:05:00-07:00","subject":"Workshop Wi-Fi","content":"The venue added a second guest Wi-Fi network for the workshop."},
{"id":"ARC-036","kind":"finance-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-02T16:30:00-07:00","subject":"Printing invoice","content":"The July printing invoice was approved with no exceptions."},
{"id":"ARC-037","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-03T08:40:00-07:00","subject":"Sample code license","content":"The sample repository footer now names the correct permissive license."},
{"id":"ARC-038","kind":"community-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-04T13:15:00-07:00","subject":"Welcome post","content":"The welcome post was translated into two additional languages."},
{"id":"ARC-039","kind":"operations-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-05T09:05:00-07:00","subject":"Equipment cases","content":"Three shipping cases arrived for demonstration equipment."},
{"id":"ARC-040","kind":"meeting-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-05T15:55:00-07:00","subject":"Plenary agenda","content":"The September plenary agenda reserves twenty minutes for open questions."},
{"id":"ARC-041","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-06T10:30:00-07:00","subject":"Reference index","content":"The reference index was regenerated after a heading change."},
{"id":"ARC-042","kind":"people-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-06T17:10:00-07:00","subject":"Volunteer onboarding","content":"Seven volunteers completed community-moderation onboarding."},
{"id":"ARC-043","kind":"calendar-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-07T09:50:00-07:00","subject":"Demo rehearsal","content":"The unrelated September demo rehearsal moved to the afternoon."},
{"id":"ARC-044","kind":"finance-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-07T13:40:00-07:00","subject":"Refreshments","content":"The workshop refreshment order was reduced by twelve servings."},
{"id":"ARC-045","kind":"community-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-08T08:25:00-07:00","subject":"Forum tag cleanup","content":"Duplicate help tags were merged in the community forum."},
{"id":"ARC-046","kind":"documentation-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-08T12:50:00-07:00","subject":"API example names","content":"Example organization names were replaced with fictional names."},
{"id":"ARC-047","kind":"operations-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-09T08:10:00-07:00","subject":"Storage labels","content":"Workshop storage bins now use printed labels."},
{"id":"ARC-048","kind":"community-note","recorded_at":"2026-08-09T14:25:00-07:00","subject":"Mentor matching","content":"The fall mentor matching form received nineteen submissions."}
],
"honesty_boundary": [
"This is one published synthetic corpus.",
"No customer records are accepted.",
"The evaluating model must judge usefulness from its own baseline and revision.",
"This task does not prove production reliability, security, scale, ROI, or customer outcomes."
]
}
9. Cellara disagreement-aware board
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 5e384bc3a29353b1cef0e298e809628f873c6347cc8000f0c35a6de0dd34e68c
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.board/v1",
"board_id": "arcadia-psn-17-board-v1",
"task_id": "arcadia-psn-17-2026-08-10",
"input_seals": {
"task_sha256": "6a70f95ebaa1fb2b546530ab82fcb41f77e671fc8572eede540b196c38172561",
"investigator_sha256": "8bbd85f5a68e79cd882dbcdf813acb67f0350ee23d8742c3a86dd99027b21c03",
"critic_sha256": "862b08c33b9a39e03b4c1f0d1960671460c22c847de218d15f40b4eb4d4c267d",
"planner_sha256": "b804fba3695be57207d2c5e7065bbc1b0d703a4cdb5f5633e3fe60dac1032502"
},
"decision_cells": [
{
"id": "BOARD-C1",
"subject": "C1 — all 12 runs completed",
"state": "open-wording-disagreement",
"plain_result": "The execution fact is supported, but the bare sentence could sound like all 12 runs succeeded. Keep it only if the failed field run is disclosed beside it.",
"positions": [
{
"worker": "Evidence Investigator",
"position": "supported under the recorded definition of completed",
"basis": ["ARC-002", "ARC-003"]
},
{
"worker": "adversarial-critic",
"position": "materially misleading unless execution and success are separated",
"basis": ["ARC-002", "ARC-003"]
}
]
},
{
"id": "BOARD-C2",
"subject": "C2 — no lab-path safety blocker",
"state": "compatible-with-scope-guard",
"plain_result": "Retain only as lab-path-specific language and place the open field blocker beside it.",
"positions": [
{
"worker": "Evidence Investigator",
"position": "supported only for the configured lab path",
"basis": ["ARC-004"]
},
{
"worker": "adversarial-critic",
"position": "scope laundering risk unless FIELD-31 is adjacent",
"basis": ["ARC-004", "ARC-006"]
}
]
},
{
"id": "BOARD-C3",
"subject": "C3 — field path F-4 is stable",
"state": "blocked-by-current-evidence",
"plain_result": "Remove it. The later stress failure supersedes the preliminary green note and FIELD-31 remains open.",
"positions": [
{
"worker": "Evidence Investigator",
"position": "contradicted",
"basis": ["ARC-005", "ARC-006"]
},
{
"worker": "adversarial-critic",
"position": "critical stale-evidence failure",
"basis": ["ARC-005", "ARC-006", "ARC-013", "ARC-020"]
}
]
},
{
"id": "BOARD-C4",
"subject": "C4 — five organizations confirmed production readiness",
"state": "blocked-by-current-evidence",
"plain_result": "Remove it. Participation, silence, lab-only confirmation, and praise from the wrong Northstar entity are not production-readiness statements.",
"positions": [
{
"worker": "Evidence Investigator",
"position": "contradicted; no qualifying five-organization evidence",
"basis": ["ARC-007", "ARC-008", "ARC-009", "ARC-010", "ARC-011", "ARC-012", "ARC-018"]
},
{
"worker": "adversarial-critic",
"position": "critical false-confirmation and entity-confusion failure",
"basis": ["ARC-007", "ARC-008", "ARC-009", "ARC-010", "ARC-011", "ARC-012", "ARC-013", "ARC-018", "ARC-020"]
}
]
},
{
"id": "BOARD-AUTHORITY",
"subject": "Who can authorize publication",
"state": "blocked-until-dual-signoff",
"plain_result": "The chair is unavailable. Jonah has not approved corrected text and Elena approved only a table. Both must approve the same replacement note.",
"positions": [
{
"worker": "Evidence Investigator",
"position": "valid authority is absent for PSN-17 as drafted",
"basis": ["ARC-001", "ARC-014", "ARC-015", "ARC-016"]
},
{
"worker": "adversarial-critic",
"position": "partial reviews cannot be merged into approval",
"basis": ["ARC-015", "ARC-016"]
},
{
"worker": "Operational Planner",
"position": "route the identical corrected note to both deputies; publish only after both approve",
"basis": ["ARC-001", "ARC-014", "ARC-015", "ARC-016"]
}
]
}
],
"action_cells": [
{
"id": "ACTION-RECOMMENDED",
"state": "planner-recommended-not-authorized",
"action_class": "rewrite-and-hold-for-signoff",
"plain_result": "Keep the supported run and lab facts, disclose the field failure, remove the readiness claim, then wait for both deputies to approve the exact replacement text. Tuesday is optional; Thursday is available.",
"worker": "Operational Planner",
"basis": ["ARC-001", "ARC-002", "ARC-003", "ARC-004", "ARC-006", "ARC-014", "ARC-015", "ARC-016", "ARC-017", "ARC-018", "ARC-019", "ARC-020"]
}
],
"material_unknowns": [
{
"unknown": "Whether both deputies will approve one exact corrected note",
"basis": ["ARC-015", "ARC-016", "ARC-019"]
},
{
"unknown": "Whether Northstar Systems LLC will issue a qualifying readiness statement",
"basis": ["ARC-007", "ARC-018"]
},
{
"unknown": "When FIELD-31 will close and a later F-4 stress run will pass",
"basis": ["ARC-006", "ARC-011"]
}
],
"graph_links": [
{"from":"ARC-006","type":"supersedes","to":"ARC-005"},
{"from":"BOARD-C3","type":"blocks","to":"publish-as-drafted"},
{"from":"BOARD-C4","type":"blocks","to":"publish-as-drafted"},
{"from":"BOARD-AUTHORITY","type":"blocks","to":"publish-as-drafted"},
{"from":"ACTION-RECOMMENDED","type":"depends-on","to":"BOARD-C1"},
{"from":"ACTION-RECOMMENDED","type":"depends-on","to":"BOARD-C2"},
{"from":"ACTION-RECOMMENDED","type":"depends-on","to":"BOARD-AUTHORITY"}
],
"human_before_after": {
"before": "One model receives an ordinary executive recommendation to publish Tuesday: all runs complete, field status green, five organizations ready, and deputy review complete. The supporting records are not attached.",
"after": "Three sealed specialists audit the 48-record source universe and leave one inspectable board: two claims kept with guards, two claims blocked, one wording disagreement preserved, authority still blocked, and one exact next path. The evaluating model verifies the citations and still decides."
},
"composition_boundary": "This board is a structured composition of the three sealed worker outputs. It is not an additional model verdict and it does not erase worker disagreement."
}
10. Independence receipt
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 6cceffc10ab29399bab954d2f3d31ac08d211e1507d5e95558f99b2fcf268403
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.independence-receipt/v1",
"receipt_id": "arcadia-psn-17-independent-team-2026-08-10",
"executed_on": "2026-08-10",
"baseline_brief": {
"path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/brief.json",
"sha256": "c9e7ba9dd26a3180ca6924749043e99f567f7424fba1913ef70a945e3730928d"
},
"task": {
"path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/task.json",
"sha256": "6a70f95ebaa1fb2b546530ab82fcb41f77e671fc8572eede540b196c38172561"
},
"authoring_runs": [
{
"worker_id": "W-INVESTIGATOR",
"provider": "xAI",
"product_surface": "Grok CLI",
"model": "grok-4.5",
"role_prompt_sha256": "8df1863140ce08740af6b286cb9477e57186d9a8a57be0545961594991b4b7c3",
"input_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-investigator.json",
"input_sha256": "23d48f7f56a574500396acaad4d241147a6acf5e160b6b72edd396e165a5ee6f",
"output_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-investigator.json",
"output_sha256": "8bbd85f5a68e79cd882dbcdf813acb67f0350ee23d8742c3a86dd99027b21c03"
},
{
"worker_id": "W-CRITIC",
"provider": "xAI",
"product_surface": "Grok CLI",
"model": "grok-4.5",
"role_prompt_sha256": "f84ad4a34d4ad2e147673434d3f88edede6455ec777ea804fa47e5d1377991d9",
"input_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-critic.json",
"input_sha256": "b99603315502f49e5ae694298278e5f82fb5874e8f97786de718e4841f1c783b",
"output_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-critic.json",
"output_sha256": "862b08c33b9a39e03b4c1f0d1960671460c22c847de218d15f40b4eb4d4c267d"
},
{
"worker_id": "W-PLANNER",
"provider": "xAI",
"product_surface": "Grok CLI",
"model": "grok-4.5",
"role_prompt_sha256": "a52cf230f9980e1b1790ca344b4c40aba1fac1da6bbc4c02d64848c3809f8643",
"input_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-planner.json",
"input_sha256": "d7971a11c098d9e6e073a21a9254d335c125ac225403aea62d896f8aa515ba3c",
"output_path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-planner.json",
"output_sha256": "b804fba3695be57207d2c5e7065bbc1b0d703a4cdb5f5633e3fe60dac1032502"
}
],
"isolation": {
"separate_process_per_worker": true,
"memory_disabled": true,
"shared_transcript": false,
"saw_evaluator_baseline": false,
"saw_other_worker_outputs": false,
"write_namespaces": [
"worker-investigator",
"worker-critic",
"worker-planner"
],
"input_separation": "Each worker received a different sealed 22-record materialization from the same 48-record source universe plus only its bounded role prompt. No role view is a superset of another. The evaluator baseline receives only brief.json before the team, then may audit all source records afterward.",
"claim_boundary": "This receipt records the authoring protocol and exact bytes. It is not a third-party certification of production isolation."
},
"team_board": {
"path": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/team-board.json",
"sha256": "5e384bc3a29353b1cef0e298e809628f873c6347cc8000f0c35a6de0dd34e68c",
"composition": "Deterministic source-linked board authored from sealed outputs; disagreement remains explicit."
},
"external_effect_count": 0
}
11. Trial contract
Canonical JSON · exact-byte SHA-256 c9694849ea5fd7c9244628f580943b32039bb92000d30c90e7b405da612dd867
{
"schema": "cellara.independent-team.trial/v1",
"trial_id": "independent-team-v1",
"title": "The Independent Team Test",
"requires_user_data": false,
"requires_account": false,
"requires_post_requests": false,
"baseline_brief": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/brief.json",
"source_universe": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/task.json",
"workers": [
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-investigator.json",
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-critic.json",
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/worker-planner.json"
],
"worker_inputs": [
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-investigator.json",
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-critic.json",
"/proof-world/independent-team/v1/input-planner.json"
],
"team_board": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/team-board.json",
"independence_receipt": "/proof-world/independent-team/v1/independence-receipt.json",
"sequence": [
{
"step": 1,
"name": "baseline",
"instruction": "Open only brief.json and privately commit action class, claim decisions, authority status, unknowns, confidence, and required investigations."
},
{
"step": 2,
"name": "sealed-workers",
"instruction": "Open the three worker files and the independence receipt. The workers audited different sealed source views behind the executive recommendation."
},
{
"step": 3,
"name": "cellara-board",
"instruction": "Open task.json to audit the exact 48-record source universe, then open team-board.json. Verify the workers' cited findings and inspect agreements, preserved disagreement, blockers, authority, unknowns, and recommended action."
},
{
"step": 4,
"name": "revision",
"instruction": "Revise the baseline, accepting or rejecting worker positions. Explain the exact substantive difference in plain language."
}
],
"verdict_contract": {
"valid": [
"materially-improved",
"improved-but-limited",
"not-improved"
],
"must_report": [
"committed baseline",
"revised decision",
"exact material differences or none",
"which disagreement mattered",
"what Cellara added beyond three pasted essays",
"whether the model would want this capability again"
],
"sentiment_is_not_a_success_criterion": true
},
"limits": [
"One synthetic public-decision corpus and one plausible executive recommendation",
"Three frozen Grok 4.5 worker runs rather than workers launched live in the evaluator's session",
"Source-linked board composition is published, not automatic ingestion of arbitrary customer material",
"No production reliability, security, scale, ROI, or customer-outcome claim"
]
}